In my journey to catalogue all vampire films, I have come upon a serious problem in my investigations. Almost all of the lists I have seen include anthologies, that is, a collection of shorter films with little to no connection to one another. But the problem does not lie with the format of anthologies, but rather the collections themselves. Take for example Mario Bava’s Black Sabbath (1963), which includes an adaptation of the novella The Family of the Vourdalak. The section itself is wonderful, and Bava’s interpretation of Tolstoy’s work is entirely captivating. But the other two stories hold absolutely zero connection to vampirism or even the Vourdalak adaptation. So the question remains: do we consider anthologies in vampire film research? or must an anthology only be included if the focal point of the collection is vampirism?
I have gone back and forth on this idea for a while, and I still can not discern a proper method to investigate these stories. And it makes it all the more difficult because I know of vampire stories that should be investigated in these collections, but that opens up a series of problems in and of itself. Primarily, if the vampire section loosely connects to the other films, then will I need to discuss the impact of the vampire section on the overall story? And on the other hand if the vampire section has no connection, then would it be deemed as a short film in my research, and I just make all the other sections null and void? Obviously there is no problem with adding these films to the catalogue on the basis of their content, far from it. But with a different format comes a different set of problems. I’m not looking for immediate solutions, but one that allows me to include stories in anthologies while not leading people astray on what any particular anthology is about.
If you have a suggestion, feel free to leave your thoughts down below!

Leave a Reply